So-o-o… “All of this has happened before.” They weren’t lying.
The rest of the show, though, was a big steaming pile of clichés and inexplicable behavior, with a side dollop of squick:
* They’re going to give up modern technology and become hunter-gatherers or primitive farmers? And this is a unanimous decision? And it remains a unanimous decision, even after everybody’s had a week to realize that being a contestant on Survivor sucks rocks?
* They’re going to scatter their tiny population across the globe rather than sticking together? Also, what’s the point of keeping records of where everyone’s gone to, if you’re no longer going to have the technology to travel between continents?
* They’re going to fly the whole starfleet into the Sun? And this is another unanimous decision? Why throw away all those resources? And why does Sam have to play kamikazi pilot? Granted, in his current state, he’d make a really crappy hunter-gatherer, but that would seem to me to be a strong argument for not becoming hunter-gatherers.
* Adama’s reaction to Roslin’s death is to permanently abandon the rest of his friends and family? It’s one thing to take some alone time after losing someone dear to you, but quite another to decide you’re never going to see other people again. I found that really weird. I found it even weirder that Lee, having somehow guessed that his father had decided to go be a hermit forever, didn’t try to talk him out of it. “At least leave me the damn Raptor so I can come see you on your birthday, Dad!” Also, no goodbye for Tigh? Dude, that’s cold.
* In order for Hera to become the Mitochondrial Eve, one of two things has to happen: either the Galactica survivors have to wipe out and replace Earth’s existing humans, or they have to interbreed with them. The finale strongly implies that the latter is what happened, which is pretty creepy if you caught the bit where Baltar says that the native humans haven’t developed language yet. So Hera, and presumably a bunch of the other cast members, are going to go off and have sex with people who can’t talk? But wait, isn’t Dollhouse a FOX show?
I also didn’t understand why the writers spent so much time on flashbacks to life before the destruction of the Twelve Colonies. Lisa proposes that by showing us how unhappy the characters all were in their former, civilized lives, the writers were trying to gin up a rationale for their final rejection of civilization. I think Lisa may be onto something here, but it still doesn’t really make sense.
If there’s a moral here, I think it’s that you should decide how your story is going to end before you start telling it, so you can build organically towards that ending rather than retconning like mad in the eleventh hour. I realize this advice is a lot easier to follow in the context of a novel than with a TV series, but still—the Cylons shouldn’t be the only ones with a plan.
It’s also worth saying that I wouldn’t be nearly as disappointed with the way BSG turned out if I hadn’t been so impressed by the first two seasons. Hopefully when they do the Space: 1999 remake, they’ll get all the way to the finish line without getting lost.
P.S. No, I haven’t heard anything about an actual Space: 1999 remake. But back in the days when I was still madly in love with BSG, I asked myself what other old SF series would be fun to try and redo, and that one was at the top of my list.